45 Forest Avenue

Out Of Market
Recommend
New Out Of Market

$5,395,000

6 Beds 7 Baths 5,864 sqft 107,639 sqft lot
45 Forest Avenue Rye City, NY
Out Of Market
Recommend

2126

Home61's Closings in

Miami, FL

Amenities

Air Conditioning
Central Heat
N/A
Refrigerator
Dishwasher
Washer
Walk-In Closets
N/A
Water View
N/A
Pool
Fence
N/A
Garage
Barbecue
N/A
Impact Windows
N/A

Key features

Living area
5,864 sqft
Lot size
107,639 sqft
Tax
$64,116   (2024)
$ /sqft
$ 920
Half Bath/WC
3
Parking Space
2
Building
-
On market
3 days
$ /sqft
$ 920
Type
house
Year Built
1930
Unit
-
Zip Code
10580
Ref./MLS ID
KEY865812

DESCRIPTION

This iconic georgian brick colonial set on over one acre, tucked behind a tree-lined drive off forest avenue in rye, ny, offers a rare blend of timeless architecture and resort-style living.  A private recreational haven awaits: a beautiful tennis/sport court, a sun-drenched newly renovated pool, spa, a charming cabana with a kitchenette and two full bathrooms offer all the ease of a luxury club, right at home.  Imagine relaxing summer days with coffee on the deck, followed by a set of tennis, and ending on a pool float with a cold beverage.  This distinguished home sits on beautifully landscaped grounds that feel far from it all, yet only minutes from the quaint downtown of rye, great restaurants, boutique shops, top-rated schools and express trains into nyc.  Verdant lawns, towering trees, and a canopy of green provide serenity.  Extensively landscaped with ornamental trees, such as bradford pears, weeping cherry, as well as rhododendrons, azaleas, peonies, hydrangea, and perennial flowers throughout.  Thirty green giant arborvitae trees offer additional privacy.  Such gardens can take decades to curate and cultivate.  A gate at the rear of the property allows you to join the fun neighborhood events that take place on drake smith lane, a double cul-de-sac.  It is the best of both worlds: private estate living and a neighborhood to enjoy.  Inside, the interiors unfold with classic detail and generous proportions.  A rounded, grand entry foyer with views straight through the home to the backyard leads to bright and beautifully scaled living spaces.  The large, classic living room is warm and inviting with a wood-burning fireplace.  The paneled library also has a wood-burning fireplace made of marble and is rich with character.  A large dining room with a walk-in wet bar updated in 2025 is ideal for entertaining.  Originally built in 1930, the home was later expanded to add a family room adjacent to the kitchen for a more modern lifestyle.  A deck was also added with a natural gas line for the bbq, and a light-filled sunroom was built, which leads to the backyard.  The family room has a wine refrigerator and built-in cabinetry.  The kitchen has an eat-in area, a thermador 6-burner range with a grilling surface, a sub-zero refrigerator, an additional under-counter sub-zero crisper, two sinks, and a bosch dishwasher.  A butler’s pantry with beautiful wood countertops and a large sink made of zinc complements the kitchen.  Upstairs, the primary bedroom has two walk-in closets with views of the pool, tennis court, and side garden.  The primary bedroom connects to a separate sitting room with french doors with a view of the entire backyard.  Across the hall is a dressing room with a walk-in closet, a storage closet, and a stackable washer and dryer.  This room would also be ideal as a nursery or an office.  The primary bathroom contains an oversized jacuzzi bathtub, a steam shower, and a bidet.  Two additional en-suite bedrooms with walk-in closets complete the second floor.  The top level features a full gym, three additional bedrooms, and a full bathroom.  The finished lower level with windows offers a wine storage room, expansive recreation space, a large laundry room, a half bath, meticulously maintained mechanical rooms, and access to a 2-car garage.  The architectural details of this home have been preserved, including beautiful oak floors, a gently curving staircase, leaded glass, brass registers, beautiful hardware, high ceilings, and more.  The home has been meticulously maintained.  The cedar shingle roof was redone in 2019.  Located close to town, the train station, highly rated midland school, rye high and rye middle school, nursery schools, the rye ymca, the rye arts center, the rye nature center, and the rye recreation center.  Enjoy all that rye has to offer: parks, the beach, the marina, many beach, golf and yacht clubs, as well as many restaurants.  Rye, new york, is just 35 minutes from manhattan.  


Data is provided by OneKey MLS.

Listed on May 27, 2025 by Kimberly H. Arenas from Compass Greater NY, LLC, this house is for sale. 6/7 house for sale in Rye City listed at $5,395,000, Reference KEY865812

The multiple listing information is provided by OneKey MLS® from a copyrighted compilation of listings. The compilation of listings and each individual listing are © 2025 OneKey MLS®. All Rights Reserved.
The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified.